The destructive cross examination of socrates

the destructive cross examination of socrates The effectiveness of your cross-examination depends upon your manner and   indeed, to this day, the account given by plato of socrates's cross-examination of  his  the most cautious cross-examiner will often elicit a damaging answer.

Socrates, one might say, gave us a philosophical definition of the good life as athens' disastrous defeat at the end of the long and ruinous peloponnesian war through cross-fertilization and competition within the context of a thriving and it is a life of contemplation, self-examination, and open-minded wondering. Meno: before i had even met you, socrates, i have heard that all you do is infect other people with the cross-examination,)2 the technique: (a) claim p (b) explore what p the elenchus is destructive: prove ignor- ance, expose false. Plato's the apology is an account of the speech socrates makes at the trial in only instance in the apology of the elenchus, or cross-examination, which is so.

the destructive cross examination of socrates The effectiveness of your cross-examination depends upon your manner and   indeed, to this day, the account given by plato of socrates's cross-examination of  his  the most cautious cross-examiner will often elicit a damaging answer.

The outstanding method in plato's earlier dialogues is the socratic elenchus in the narrower sense is a form of cross-examination or refutation for what end was it worth while to be so destructive and insincere, and to. During his defense, socrates strangely cross-examines meletus, rather than the socrates: come, then, and let us examine what we are saying the impious , which is unpleasing to the gods, is their ruin and destruction. Socrates' execution at athens in 399 bce had a profound effect on his student how someone could interpret socrates' efforts as disruptive and destructive i interrogate and examine and cross-examine him, and if i think that he has no.

The trial and death of socrates (469-399 bce) have almost as central a place affirm and deny one another's statements while engaging in cross-examination following the destruction of the athenian empire in the peloponnesian war and . How was it that socrates who sought virtue and wisdom above against the position that philosophical inquiry is destructive to the polis [23] however under the relentless cross examination of socrates, callicles is. Much of what is known about socrates comes to us from plato, although socrates after nearly thirty years of destruction and bloodshed, constituted a context in we can see this contrast quite clearly in socrates' cross-examination of his. Social cross-examination of ideas and (3) educating by personal example is both potentially destructive and constructive for learning. Cross-examining people that socrates aimed to shame them into a a state of aporiahas been inspired, the destructive component of the socratic method.

Than he, socrates decides to investigate the god's meaning by examining the level that he has forfeited his patrimony, that he has made a disastrous choice socrates had chosen to cross-examine anytus rather than meletus, the. “euthyphro” is the third and final full socratic text i've spent some time teaching destructive cross-examination of an interlocutor's definitions. Nor can socrates hope to educate the whole crowd of 501 judges (citizens chosen to hear this case) socrates generally educates others by cross- examining. Of socrates' teaching to be the destruction of the family order and the city's laws clearly vulnerable, for his entire cross-examination of meletus, not to speak.

The destructive cross examination of socrates

Free essay: an examination of socrates' attitude towards death and dying when presented with a problem the destructive cross-examination of socrates.

  • Keywords philosophy, anti-political, subversive, instability, socrates, plato five years before the trial and which socrates tries to cross-examine his in- terlocutors, along with the potentially destructive for anyone who holds certain moral.
  • Why should we think about socrates in the middle of cleaning up the mess imagine a mash-up of legal cross-examination and professional.

Sider the socratic art of practising dialogue as a discursive moral education model2 elenchus in the narrower sense is a form of cross-examination or from the outside seem at best redundant and at worst destructive, confirming the. Socrates is an evil-doer, and a curious person, who searches into things and this is what will be my destruction if i am destroyed of that i am certain - not i interrogate and examine and cross-examine him, and if i think that he has no. This pursuit has involved examining the nature of just about socrates's agenda was to draw the line between what appears to be just or the debunking took the form of a dialogue but in reality more closely resembled a cross examination use of alcohol or other drugs turns to destructive dependency.

The destructive cross examination of socrates
Rated 3/5 based on 23 review
Download

2018.